2015年2月12日星期四

Reader Response draft 2

In the article “Writing Your Way to Happiness”,  Parker-Pope (2015) states that writing one’s own experience can develop mental health and bring a good mood to give people the happiness. The author believes that our world outlook and self-positioning depends on these personal statements.These claims were illustrated by examples. Stanford researchers once carried out a study on the college freshmen. Results showed that writing could encourage people and give them confidence towards their future. Parker-Pope also mentions that writing can help people to face the difficulties in their life truly. By taking example of a woman Siri in the Johnson & Johnson Human Performance Institute, she realized her real problems through writing.It is asserted in the article that writing indeed helps you recognize what hinders you and lead you towards the happiness. 

However, writing and editing one's stories is not sufficient to cause happiness and improve physical health.

In the article, the author states that "by writing and then editing our own stories, we can change our perceptions of ourselves". In order to be happy and shed the negativity, people are trying to subjectively ignore their shortcomings and delete them from their stories. By doing so, they can have more positive attitude to live on their lives. However, only looking at the good side of oneself is not helpful in keeping happy in the long term. Through editing, people will get into an imaginary story easily and wallow in an unreal happiness. Belmer (2013) mentions that in order to achieve happiness, people have to be honest about themselves. Even though people can put more attention on their strength, they still need to know their weaknesses well.After getting know oneself better, they can be more rational and treat things in a maturer way. There are less trifles that bothering them and this will make them enjoy a more happy life.


Furthermore, the author believes that people can realize the real problems that stopping them from happiness through express writing. It is true that writing allows people to calm down and tell the true obstacles. However, writing does not give them the solutions to those problems. In reality, sometimes people actually know about what real problems are, they just deny them and get stuck. Writing indeed is a way to talk to oneself. It becomes difficult for people to solve those problems when they do not want to admit those problems. Instead of talking to oneself, Williamson(2014) and King(2014) states that "our relationships with other people are the most important thing for our happiness". People need to build close and strong relationship with someone else and looking for the solutions to the problems together with people surrounding. This is an effective and much useful tool to move away the obstacles on their ways towards happiness. For instance, there are many suicide of young people all over the world.From their last words, most of them were struggling against something and finally could not get over them.In such situation, expressive writing gives little help.In order to achieve happiness, writing is not sufficient and people ought to get more suggestions from their trusted ones as well to really solve those problems.

The author also argues that writing about personal experiences can improve one's physical health,like reducing symptoms among cancer patients. However, in my point of view, writing is just a way to shift their attention to other aspects. It is not sufficient and they need more physical exercise to maintain health, including mental health. For most of the people, being overweight or not eating nutritious foods can have a negative effect on their mood.These root of unhappiness cannot simply solved by express writing. Widrich(2014) mentions that exercise is a cure for nearly everything in life and leads people to the happiness. Exercise has been known to have a positive impact boosting self-esteem, sense of control and endorphin levels which gives people a feeling of happiness.According to these evidences, physical exercise is also essential to have happiness.

All in all,Parker-Pope's assertion that express writing can help people to achieve happiness is complete as there are lots of other important elements on the way to happiness.

Word count:694 words

References:

Tara Parker-Pope.(Jan 19,2015). Writing Your Way to Happiness[Weblog post].Retrieved from http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/01/19/writing-your-way-to-happiness/?_r=0

Cynthia Belmer.(Feb 22,2013). 17 Ways to Shed Nagativity and Achieve Happiness.[Mindbodygreen].Retrieved from  http://www.mindbodygreen.com/0-7806/17-ways-to-shed-negativity-and-achieve-happiness.html

Mark Williamson & Vanessa King.(Nov 3,2014).Ten Easier Step to Happier Living.[Weblog post].Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/nov/03/ten-easy-steps-that-will-make-you-a-happier-person

Leo Widrich.(Feb 4,2014).What Happens to Our Brains When We Exercise and How It Makes Us Happier.[Weblog post].Retrieved from http://www.fastcompany.com/3025957/work-smart/what-happens-to-our-brains-when-we-exercise-and-how-it-makes-us-happier

2 条评论:

  1. 1) self-positioning depends - depend

    2)By taking example of a woman Siri – There shoulb be a comma after the woman and “an” after the taking.

    leads you towards the

    is not sufficient –are

    to cause happiness and improve physical health. – “bring” sounds better

    However, only looking at the good side of oneself is not helpful in keeping happy in the long term.

    * In leading a happy …

    wallow in an unreal happiness

    * “an” is not needed , bcos happiness is uncountable noun

    .After getting to know oneself better, they can be more rational and treat things in a mature way. There are less trifles that bothering them and this will make them enjoy a more happy life.

    * There will be less trifles that will bother them. Thus, they will enjoy a happier …

    real problems that stop them from happiness through expressive writing. It is true that writing allows people to calm down and recognise their real obstacles. However, writing does not give them the solutions to those problems. In reality, sometimes people might actually know what real the problems are, yet they just deny them and get stuck.

    It becomes difficult for people to solve their problems when they do not want to admit those. Instead of talking to oneself, Williamson(2014) and King(2014) state that "our relationships with other people are the most important thing for our happiness". People need to build close and strong relationship with someone else and look for the solutions to the problems together. This is an effective and much useful tool to move the obstacles away. For instance, there are many suicide cases of young people all over the world.From their last words, most of them were struggling against something but finally could not resolve them .In such a situation, expressive writing helps least.In order to achieve happiness, writing is not sufficient. People ought to get more suggestions from their trusted which helps them solve their issues.

    * their attentions to other as

    * negative effects on their moods

    * These causes of unhappiness cannot be simply solved by expressive writing.

    All in all,Parker-Pope's assertion that express writing can help people to achieve happiness is complete as there are lots of other important elements on the way to happiness.

    * What do you mean by Pope’s assertion is complete?

    Have a clear topic sentence, and the rest of the article can also support your opinion.

    Good job for using examples

    The reference for the Mindbody…. Article is of the type article published only online. And I believe the other refernces will be similar to this type too.


    Pryanga and Limin

    回复删除
  2. Thank you, JueTong, for this good effort. You present a fairly clear and comprehensive summary, and a detailed, well supported response. Your thesis also seems clear. Just as importantly, this is an interesting essay to read. The fact that you document your own ideas with outside resources makes the argument more sound.

    One problem in this post is your conclusion. It doesn't seem to follow from the other ideas or your thesis.

    Another problem in this essay is the accumulation of language errors. These are a few areas to consider though:

    --- By taking example of a woman Siri in the Johnson & Johnson Human Performance Institute, she realized her real problems through writing. >>>

    Who is "taking (the) example of a woman (named) Siri? "She"? Or Parker-Pope?

    --- ... writing indeed helps you recognize what hinders you and lead you towards the happiness. >> Me? Using "you" (or "I" or "we") is too conversational.) How can you change this sentence?

    --- After getting know oneself better, they... >>>
    After getting TO know themselves better, they...

    --- a maturer way. >>> maturer?

    --- that stopping them >>> verb form?

    --- Williamson(2014) and King(2014) states ... >>>
    Williamson and King (2014) state that...

    ---- close and strong relationship >>> a close and strong relationship (why?)

    --- much useful tool >>> much used tool / very useful

    --- many suicide >>> plural?

    --- ...among cancer patients. However, in my point of view, writing is just a way to shift their attention to other aspects.

    >>> Aspects? Meaning?

    --- It is not sufficient and they need exercise... >> just? logic?

    --- Your reference list does not follow APA style.

    I look forward to your next draft.

    回复删除